She questioned the motives of the responer, but still chose it as the best answer?!?!?
Maybe she thought, that Captain
gave her the right spell, she changed her mind and didn't want to become a mermaid anymore.
I don't know if this person was trying to make me kill myself,
Because I know there is alot [sic] more to life then [sic] war and hate. I want to escape fromit [sic] all.
She didn't realize, that the responder was giving her a clue how to make it happen.
One has to love that logic